Vetoes During 2005 - 2006 Session 

VETO NO.

DATE

BILL

SUBJECT

DISPOSITION AND LINKS

1 of 2005

Dec. 23

HB 515

Amends the Tax Reform Code by reducing the personal income tax from 3.07% to 3.05% within calendar year 2007 and for each taxable year thereafter. The bill also states that for taxable years beginning before January 1, 2007, all business income would be apportioned to PA by multiplying the income by a fraction: the numerator of which is the property factor plus the payroll factor plus three times the sales factor; and the denominator of which is five. For taxable years beginning in calendar year 2007, all business income would be apportioned to PA by multiplying the income by a fraction: the numerator of which is the sum of fifteen times the property factor, fifteen times the payroll factor and seventy times the sales factor; and the denominator of which is one hundred. Additionally, the bill increases the net operating loss deduction from $2,000,000 up to $10,000,000 for taxable years beginning in calendar year 2009. Lastly, the legislation defines the term "manufacture" when in relation to the sales and use tax.

Governor’s Veto Message 

 

2 of 2005

Dec. 23

HB 603

Amends Title 71 (State Government) by defining "enforcement officer" to include Game Commission officers and other commissioned law enforcement personnel employed by the Game Commission who have and exercise the same law enforcement powers as Game Commission officers. The paragraph does not apply to deputy Game Commission officers.

 

                   2006

Governor’s Veto Message

 

VETO NO.

DATE

BILL

SUBJECT

DISPOSITION AND LINKS

1 of 2006

Mar. 15

HB 1318

Amends the PA Election Code providing for requirements relating to voter identification; further providing for powers and duties of county boards, for compensation of district election officers, for polling places selected by county boards, for public buildings to be used where possible and portable polling places and for prohibiting polling places in buildings where malt or brewed beverages or liquors are sold; providing for polling places in other buildings; further providing for nominations by political bodies and for affidavits of candidates; and further providing for opening of polls, posting cards of instruction and notices of penalties and voters' rights and examination of voting machines, for voting procedures, for manner of applying to vote, for date of application for absentee ballots, for canvassing of official absentee ballots and for violation of provisions relating to absentee voting. The Department of Transportation would issue identification cards at no cost to any registered elector who has made application therefor and has included with the completed application a signed affidavit stating that the elector is unable to obtain another form of photo identification, including a driver's license, that the elector is unable to pay the required fee for the identification card and that the elector is a registered elector. Compensation for judges of election is increased to a minimum of $75 (from $45), for inspectors of election to a minimum of $75 (from $45), and for clerks and machine operators to a minimum of $70 (from $40). The location of a polling place may not be changed except in the case of an emergency occurring within 20 days (increased from 10) of an election. The county board of elections would publicly announce within 20 days of an election, by posting at its office in a conspicuous place, a list of the places at which the election is to be held in the various election districts of the county. In selecting polling places, the county board of elections would make every effort to select polling places that provide all electors with an environment that is free from intimidation and violence. If no polling place is available 20 days prior to an election, a public building situated in immediately adjacent ward may be selected. No election may be held in a room where alcohol is dispensed, may be held in a room that is accessible only through a room where alcohol is served, and no alcohol may be served in a building where a polling place is located while the polls are open. No election may be held in any of the following: (1) a private residence not situated within the boundaries of the election district; (2) a private residence of an elected or appointed party official; (3) a private residence, that is not otherwise prohibited unless the county board of elections certifies in writing and at a public hearing that the polling place located within the private residence is accessible to persons with disabilities and the private residence is a location free of intimidation and harassment; (4) an abandoned building; (5) a vacant lot; (6) an office, building or private residence of a candidate for political office; (7) an office, building or private residence of an elected official; or (8) a building utilized by a ward or political party as headquarters. A candidate must affirm that he is not a candidate for an office which he already holds, the term of which is not set to expire in the same year as the office subject to the affidavit. A notice pertaining to voters' rights must be posted. The notice would contain the following in boldface type: An elector would have the right to cast his or her vote: without the use or threat of force, violence or restraint; without the infliction or threat of infliction of injury; without any intimidation or coercion upon or against his or her person; or without any other action intended to deny any individual's right to vote. Identification would be required each time an elector votes. A provisional ballot would not be counted if the elector fails to present to the county board of elections, at the challenge hearing or prior thereto, a form of identification required. An application for absentee ballot that is received by the office of the county board of elections earlier than 50 days before the primary or election would be held and processed upon commencement of the 50-day period. Lastly, the legislation outlines procedures for applying for and receiving absentee ballots.

Bill, together with Governor’s Veto Message, laid on the table, March 20, 2006.

 

2 of 2006

Mar. 17

HB 1467

The Residential Construction Dispute Resolution Act establishes dispute resolution procedures relating to residential construction defects between contractors and homeowners or members of associations. A claimant would, no later than 75 days before initiating an action against a contractor, provide service of written notice of claim on the contractor, which would state that the claimant asserts a construction defect claim or claims and is providing notice of the claim or claims pursuant to the requirements of this act. The notice of claim would describe the claim or claims sufficiently to explain the nature of the alleged construction defects and if known the results of the defects. The act would not apply to any claim for personal injury or death.

Bill, together with Governor’s Veto Message laid on the table, March 20, 2006.

3 of 2006

Mar. 24

SB 435

Amends Title 42 (Judiciary) providing for comparative negligence by adding that where recovery is allowed against more than one person, including actions for strict liability, and where liability is attributed to more than one defendant, each defendant would be liable for that proportion of the total dollar amount awarded as damages in the ratio of the amount of that defendant's liability to the amount of liability attributed to all defendants and other persons to whom liability is apportioned. Also, a defendant's liability would be several and not joint, and the court would enter a separate and several judgment in favor of the plaintiff and against each defendant for the apportioned amount of that defendant's liability. Nothing in this section would be construed in any way to create, abolish or modify a cause of action or to limit a party's right to join another potentially responsible party.

Bill, together with Governor’s Veto Message

laid on the table, March 27, 2006.

4 of 2006

May 16

SB 997

Amends the Public Welfare Code further providing for medical assistance payments for institutional care by removing the provision stating that the promulgation of regulations under this subsection would, until June 30, 2006, be exempt from Section 205 of the Commonwealth Documents Law, Section 204(b) of Commonwealth Attorneys Act, and the Regulatory Review Act. The bill also states that on or after July 1, 2006, payments to county and nonpublic nursing facilities certified to participate as providers under Title XIX of the Social Security Act for nursing facility services would be calculated and made as specified in the department's regulations in effect on July 1, 2003, except as may be otherwise required by the Commonwealth's approved Title XIX Plan for nursing facility services.

Bill, together with Governor’s Veto Message laid on the table, June 5, 2006.

5 of 2006

July 11

HB 1195

Amends the Storage Tank and Spill Prevention Act by removing the provision that states that only fill pipes of underground storage tanks "which have not been upgraded" are eligible for sealing under the Underground Storage Tank Pollution Prevention Program. The bill also requires the Underground Storage Tank Indemnification Board to perform a study which evaluates costs attributed to the remediation of storage tank spills containing methyl tertiary butyl ether (MBTE) and the potential impact to the fund. The study would also make recommendations as to whether fees, payment levels or board policy should be adjusted to meet potential liability of cleanups related to MTBE and it shall be submitted to the Senate and House Environmental Resources and Energy Committees by March 15, 2007.

Governor’s Veto Message

6 of 2006

July 11

HB 1928

Amends Title 75 (Vehicles) further providing for permits for movement of a mobile home or a modular housing unit and modular housing undercarriage. The bill specifies that up to three empty modular undercarriages may be stacked on top of another undercarriage for movement if they are securely fastened. The permit would not be issued for movement during a holiday period or during inclement weather. It also provides for a special hauling permit for metallic hot boxes. The bill also requires standard running lights at all times during the movement of a mobile home or a modular housing unit and modular housing undercarriage. The department would promulgate all necessary regulations for the use and operation of standard running lights.

Governor’s Veto Message

7 of 2006

Oct. 27

HB 1813

Act providing for the allocation of funds to county mental health and mental retardation programs stating that the Secretary of the Budget would include in the budget submission to the General Assembly the amounts required for certain funding. The bill provides for a calculation of index adjustment. Also, the bill states that funds included in the governor's budget submission for the community mental health, community mental retardation services and early intervention services programs would be identified as increases in the rates or amounts of funding for existing community-based mental health and mental retardation services.

Governor’s Veto Message

8 of 2006

Oct. 27

HB 2545

Amends Title 53 (Municipalities Generally) further providing for the regulation of taxicab and limousine service within the city of Philadelphia by the Philadelphia Parking Authority. Provides an exception for a limousine carrier or taxicab based outside the city of Philadelphia and certified by the Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission.

Governor’s Veto Message

9 of 2006

Nov. 3

HB 236

Amends the Regulatory Review Act further providing for legislative intent, for proposed regulations and procedure for review. "Small business" is defined to mean a business entity including its affiliates that is independently owned or operated and has less than 100 full time employees or has gross annual sales of less than $6 million. The act is intended to improve State rulemaking by creating procedures to analyze the availability of more flexible regulatory approaches for small businesses in accordance with certain findings. For any regulation subject to the act, a small business that is adversely affected or aggrieved by final agency action is entitled to judicial review of agency compliance for a period of 18 months from the date of the final agency action. The act is not intended to create a right or benefit, substantive or procedural, enforceable at law by a person against another person or against the Commonwealth, its agencies or its officers.

Governor’s Veto Message

10 of 2006

Nov. 9

HB 2202

Amends the Public Welfare Code by providing for medical assistance payments for home infusion therapy. The following medical assistance payments would be made on behalf of persons eligible for prescription drug coverage and who have a valid prescription for home infusion therapy: (1) prescription pharmaceuticals; (2) professional pharmacy services, and (3) home infusion nursing visits. "Home infusion therapy" means the preparation of parenteral pharmaceuticals, which are prescription drugs and biologics administered through catheters and/or needles, provided in a patient's home, other place of residence or outpatient setting. Parenteral routes of administration include intravenous, intraspinal, intrathecal, intra-arterial, subcutaneous and intramuscular. Home infusion therapy also involves clinical pharmacy monitoring as well as clinical nursing for the administration, teaching and oversight of the patient's prescribed parenteral therapy.

Governor’s Veto Message

11 of 2006

Nov. 9

HB 2282

Amends the Tax Reform Code further providing, in hotel occupancy tax, for definitions and for imposition of tax by adding that no political subdivision may impose or authorize the imposition of a hotel tax, hotel room rental tax, tourism and marketing tax or similar tax, or require the collection of such tax, to a greater extent than 6%, as imposed by this Act. Additionally, the bill provides for classes of income by including, in personal income tax, income from the US Government or the Commonwealth of PA for active State duty for emergency within or outside PA, including duty ordered pursuant to 35 Pa.C.S. Ch. 76 (relating to Emergency Management Assistance Compact). This would apply to taxable years beginning after December 31, 2006.

Governor’s Veto Message

12 of 2006

Nov. 9

SB 157

Amends the Local Tax Enabling Act renaming the "Emergency Municipal Services Tax" (EMST) to the "Local Services Tax" and removing the provision that prohibits municipalities/school districts from requiring employers to withhold the tax in installments. Also generally allows only the municipality/school district in which the employee is primarily employed to levy the LST. Further provides for a low income exemption, an annual rate limitation and restricted use of the revenue from the LST.

Bill, together with the Governor’s Veto Message, laid on the table, November 15, 2006.

13 of 2006

Nov. 29

HB 471

Amends the Administrative Code providing for the procedure to transfer appropriations between funds; extending the time period covered by an application considered for the Merchant Marine World War II Veterans Bonus to June 30, 2007 and extending the expiration of the Merchant Marine World War II Veterans Bonus Act to June 30, 2008; making inconsistent repeals relating to the Merchant Marine World War II Veterans Bonus Act; requiring the Department of Transportation to prepare daily logs of all travel on state-owned aircraft; establishing the Cardiovascular Disease Advisory Committee and a Statewide stroke database by the Department of Health; providing for biennial renewal of physicians' licenses for volunteer health services; and providing for regulation by political subdivisions of public smoking at certain licensed facilities and reporting by Department of Health on public smoking ordinances.

Governor’s Veto Message

Line Item Vetoed Legislation for 2006

DATE

BILL

SUBJECT

DISPOSITION AND LINKS

May 11, 2006

HB 2380

Amends the General Appropriation Act of 2005 increasing the State's appropriation to the PA Housing Finance Agency for the Homeowner's Emergency Mortgage Assistance Program to $8 million from $5 million. The bill adds an appropriation of $5,063,000 to the Attorney General for reimbursement to counties for expenses for full-time district attorneys. The bill also adds an appropriation of $500,000 for the Merchant Marine World War II Veterans' Bonus Fund. The bill appropriates $3,066,000 from the General Fund and $8,289,000 from the Motor License Fund for the recruitment, training and deployment of an additional 180 State Police troopers during the 2005-2006 fiscal year. The appropriation to the Attorney General for reimbursement to counties for full-time district attorneys would be a continuing appropriation until March 31, 2007.

Bill, together with Governor’s Line Item Veto Message laid on the table, June 5, 2006.

 

Line Item Vetoed Legislation for 2005

 DATE

BILL

SUBJECT

DISPOSITION AND LINKS

July 7, 2005

HB 815

This is the General Appropriation Act of 2005 providing for expenses of the Executive, Legislative and Judicial Departments, the public debt, for the public schools for the fiscal year July 1, 2005, to June 30, 2006.

Governor’s Line Item Veto Message

 

 

***When the Governor exercises the item veto power, he returns to the Chamber which originated the bill a letter which identifies which item or items he is not approving. This letter contains the same language as the actual item veto signed by the Governor and attached to the bill before filing it with the Department of State, as required by the Pennsylvania Constitution.

 

***A letter provides the Governor’s explanation of why he vetoed certain items. It accompanies the item veto letter to the General Assembly and provides a more detailed discussion of his reasons behind the item veto.